Skip to main content.


Petenwell Lake Homes For Sale Through Castle Rock Realty

Castle Rock Realty offers a variety of homes for sale in the Petenwell Lake area and the cities of Mauston, Necedah, New Lisbon, Lyndon Station, Elroy, Adams, Friendship, Wisconsin Dells, Lake Delton and Tomah in Central Wisconsin as well as villages in the surrounding area. The central Wisconsin counties of Juneau, Adams, Sauk, Columbia and Monroe offer numerous quality living opportunities.

Petenwell Lake Area Homes

Water Access Listing 1770920 Photos

Petenwell Lake - Big Bay - Newer construction 3 bedroom, 2 bath home with access to Petenwell Lake. This well maintained home offers a rustic feel with a great room that is finished in knotty pine and a stone fireplace. The kitchen is open to the great room that features vaulted ceilings to make the area feel more spacious. Full basement that is ready to be finished off for extra living space. Plus there is a 2 stall attached garage to store your toys. This home is in a waterfront development on Petenwell Lake and offers pair rights, so you can keep your boat in the water. bjb



Virtual Tour

Water Access Listing 1737784 Photos

Petenwell Lake - Southview Shores - There is nothing average about this custom built, log sided home with pier rights to Petenwell Lake. This high quality hime offers Granite Countertops / Hickory Cabinets / Tile Flooring with In-Floor Heat / Forced Air handling system with heat & central A/C / Custom Gas Grille with hood vent built into the kitchen island / Free Standing Pellet Stove / 16' x 20' Screen Room with a Hot Tub connected to the spacious back deck & there is even a concrete storm shelter. Secluded enough for lots of peace & quiet. pmm



Virtual Tour

Waterfront Listing 1729005 Photos

Petenwell Lake - Grand View - Newer construction all brick home on Lake Petenwell. Great views of Wisconsin's 2nd largest lake from this home. This home sits secluded on 2.5 acres. 3 bedroom, 2 bath home with an open concept kitchen and living area overlooking the water. Quality materials were used in building this home, a combination of ceramic and wood flooring throughout, all brick exterior, brick fireplace and much more. Full basement that is ready to be finished off and is plumbed for another bathroom. 3+ stall garage. Great price bjb



Virtual Tour

Waterfront Listing 1764358 Photos

Petenwell Lake - Petenwell Corp. - 200' of Private Frontage on Petenwell Lake PLUS a shared interest a 50' x 150' Storage Building just a block away. This unique property also includes a 15' x 30' Boathouse with a trolley system, a walk-out basement and a nice tuck-under garage on the lake side of the house. The view is unbelievable and a property like this does not come onto the market very often. New forced air furnace and central air system. pmm



Virtual Tour

Waterfront Listing 1743578 Photos

Petenwell Lake - Pinewood Shores - Northwoods on the inside - Maintenance Free on the outside. This Amish built home was designed by an engineer & includes many features that make ownership & maintenance a real pleasure. It includes an Insulated Foam Concrete foundation / Closed Loop Geo-Thermal Heating & Air Conditioning / Solar Power that keeps Elect. cost at only about $35 / mo. Fire resistant shingles, exterior and deck / LP back-up heat & Gas Fireplace. Full Basement roughed in for a full bath and a 25'x36' Garage with 12' tall doors. pmm



Virtual Tour

Waterfront Listing 1728327 Photos

Petenwell Lake - Big Bay - Includes all furniture & appliances !! This custom built 4 bd./ 4 ba. waterfront home on Lake Petenwell offers a master bedroom suite with jacuzzi, first floor 9ft ceilings, solid 6 Panel oak doors, ceramic tile with in-floor heating, Anderson windows & top of the line oak hardwood floors. There are 2 gas fireplaces, custom oak cabinetry with solid granite countertops through out, 1st and 2nd floor bars as well as a wet bar on 1st floor. pmm



Virtual Tour

Waterfront Listing 1750745 Photos

Petenwell Lake - Big Bay - Log Home with 124' of frontage & a spectacular view of Petenwell Lake. This 3-4 bedroom home easily sleeps 16 with the newly finished Bonus Room. The wrap around deck offers lots of room for outdoor entertaining. There is also a custom built fire-pit & sandbox. Inside boasts a stone fireplace, kitchen island, a full 2-story view of the lake & a doggy bathtub in the laundry room. Heated 4 Car garage provides plenty of room for your vehicles & water toys. Exterior was just re-stained and looks brand new. pmm



Virtual Tour

Image 01 Image 02 Image 03 Image 04 Image 05